← Vela Decisions
Vela DecisionsSample brief · Illustrative

Governance & Accountability · Decision 1

The Green Light

The decision

Management recommended accelerating the rollout of an AI-driven lending platform. Independent testing had identified unresolved concerns about how the model performs under certain economic conditions. Management believed the risks could be managed after launch. The board was asked to approve the investment.

What happened next

Four months later, rates rose sharply. Defaults in one customer segment ran at twice the model's forecast. The monitoring dashboard promised to the board had not been built, and the first sign reached the board through a regulator's information request.

How directors split

Approve38%
Approve subject to conditions47%
Defer for more evidence15%

Assumptions that split the room

Monitoring will catch problems earlyTesting reflects real economic conditionsManagement will escalate bad news quickly

What changed minds

Directors who moved after the development most often cited the missing dashboard: a condition of approval that no one had tracked.

What the record should show

That the board understood the testing gap, set specific conditions for launch, assigned an owner for each, and asked to see evidence that the conditions had been met before the next stage.

Questions for your next meeting

  1. What conditions in the economy would cause this model to stop performing as tested, and how would we know?
  2. Which commitments made to secure approval have actually been delivered?
  3. Who has the authority to pause a launch the board has already approved?
  4. What would management have to tell us for us to reverse this decision?
  5. Where in our minutes does it show how we weighed the testing concerns?
Illustrative sample. Scenario is fictionalized; results shown are not member data. Vela does not provide legal advice.velaboards.com